There are so many errors in this story it's hard to belive ACD even had an editor. Maybe he didn't. Even before I read the annotated 'criticisms' in the version I was reading Click little read of a mystery I won't remember tomorrow - something about poultry and a hat. Nicely performed by Alan Cumming; he of course is the only reason I bothered listening to it. This was a free audiobook from Audible for the holiday season, and the fact that Alan Cumming was the narrator is the only reason I downloaded it. I am not a huge fan of the Sherlock Holmes canon, but I adore Alan Cumming and thought he would be an excellent test to see how deep my dislike of Holmes runs.
- Data! Data! Data! – The Blue Carbuncle | The Fourth Garrideb - Numismatics of Sherlock Holmes?
- The Adventure of the Blue Carbuncle (The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes, #7);
- Saving Lincoln;
- One Breath.
Even with Mr. Cummings wonderful Acclaimed biologist Lewis Wolpert eloquently narrates the basics of human life through the lens of its smallest component: the cell. Everything about our existence-movement and memory, imagination and reproduction, birth, and ultimately death-is governed by our cells.
They are the basis of all life Best-selling authors, celebrities, entrepreneurs, teachers, philosophers, lawyers, social workers, and martial arts gurus come together to share their experiences of having been bullied, coming to terms with themselves, and You may also find other subjects related with The Valley of the Lost.
Crafting likable, interesting characters is a balancing act, and finding that perfect mix of strengths and weaknesses can be difficult. But the task has become easier thanks to The Negative Trait Thesaurus. Through its flaw-centric exploration of character arc, motivation, emotional wounds, and Meeson's Will is the story of mean Mr. Doyle didn't like his detective much, but Sherlock's knife-edged intellect and fascination with puzzles are strangely hypnotic -- even if you wouldn't like to be roomies with the guy, it would be amazing just to sit and watch him work. Watson is the perfect counterpoint for Holmes: And how good is the annotation for this book?
In fact, they're too dense at times, leaving you wishing for a little more brevity in the annotation. This Annotated Edition from Norton is exquisite! This is a review of just the Adventures, and I'll add in the Memoirs and the New Annotated as a whole later on. A really fascinating study of Sherlock Holmes. As I've said in my review of Study of Scarlet, it really helps to read this and appreciate it, not try to follow along with the mystery.
I liked all of the odd cases that Sherlock has taken on and the different views of him and Watson as the cases go on. Holmes is definitely a very peculiar man, even if you take away his amazing deductive skills and I think that these short stories highlight those peculiarities. This book went quicker both times I have read The Adventures and the Memoirs together, but I think it's in part that there's not much too them. Sherlock is still brilliant and Watson is awesome and the two of them together are love, but the tales go by quickly.
I think it's in part because Sherlock is less studied by Watson and more just written about.
The Adventure of the Blue Carbuncle - Annotated Version
Still, there are several interesting stories in here that I enjoyed. The comments range from explanations of Victorian Britain to comparisons between the full range of Sherlock stories, to the many theories that people have come up with over the years. The editor writes this book as if Holmes and Watson were actual people and Doyle merely published the stories on behalf of Watson.
There were several comments to this belief and it highly amused me. The various theories put forth by a slew of scholars over the years had me talking back to the book at different points. There were also a multitude of illustrations throughout.
All of the illustrations from Paget as well some from the different newspapers that published the stories in America. There were also pictures of places in Victorian London and several other period showings. The Annotated was well worth the read, especially if you have read Sherlock Holmes before. If you're interested, I've read The Adventures and Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes before without the annotation and you can read my past review here.
Jan 18, Stephanie rated it really liked it Shelves: The main thing that bothered me was that these volumes are based on the conceit that Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Also, I skipped many of the annotations, as they went very in depth about places buildings, streets, coun The main thing that bothered me was that these volumes are based on the conceit that Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Also, I skipped many of the annotations, as they went very in depth about places buildings, streets, counties mentioned in the stories, and it didn't need or desire to read more than a sentence or two if any about, for example, where Whitehall St.
I was expecting more of the notes to be about archaic references, or, for example, the very interesring one of why Holmes is always depicted in popular lore as wearing a deerstalker hat answer: Number of times Holmes is mentioned as wearing a deerstalker: TWO; and it is not even referred to as a "deerstalker. Of course, I feel purchasing the volumes was worth it for the stories alone and SOME of the extra information.
Jul 22, Ned rated it liked it. I still don't care for this annotated version, though. The footnotes half the time contain spoilers for the very story you are reading and the other half contain endless theorizi I am reading the entire Sherlock Holmes canon in order, and it is good that I persevered through "A Study in Scarlet," "The Sign of Four," and "The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes" to reach "The Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes. The footnotes half the time contain spoilers for the very story you are reading and the other half contain endless theorizing trying to reconcile Arthur Conan Doyle's countless careless continuity errors.
Apparently, large numbers of people amuse themselves by trying to treat the Sherlock stories as fact and constructing various whimsical and outlandish theories to explain away the errors. Had I not done the same for religion for many years, I might find this amusing. Jul 01, Micah Lasher rated it it was amazing Shelves: The introductory and supplementary material is excellent, as are the annotations, by and large. I must admit, however, that I began to mostly ignore the annotations about a third of the way in, reading the stories without interruption or distraction.
I was struck by how well Conan Doyle's Holmes and Watson hold up: The language is unadorned and straightforward, yet Watson's voice is unmistakeable and much less of a caricature than we have become used to in television and film representations. The mysteries are fun and each digestible in a single sitting. I loved Sherlock Holmes as a child and was glad to reacquaint myself.
I look forward to tackling the remaining two volumes and even more to sharing these stories with my boys when they are just a bit older. Jul 16, Susan rated it it was amazing Shelves: I thought this was a wonderful introduction to Sherlock Holmes. A lot of notes about the era, the area, and the slang used. However, if you don't like the idea of pretending the characters are real, some of the notes will drive you crazy, as the author announces in the introduction that they will treat them as such, and references interesting or outlandish theories about different events.
I rather enjoyed it as my first Sherlock Holmes book, but recognize that many people can't stand the "light I thought this was a wonderful introduction to Sherlock Holmes. I rather enjoyed it as my first Sherlock Holmes book, but recognize that many people can't stand the "light fiction" used by the author. Be warned, it's a hefty book, but considering all the notes, the introduction with the theorized lives of Holmes and Watson and Sir Doyle's life, and the timeline at the end including important events for everything from the character's lives to the world at large, it's not surprising.
I would definitely recommend it. Oct 04, Rebecca rated it it was amazing. There is not much to review on the stories of literature's greatest detective. Sherlock Holmes is engaging, quirky, and a master of detail. Watson is a faithful storyteller who never quite seems to be on the same page as Holmes, and is okay with that. This is my first time reading a collection of the stories I've read a few individual ones here and there , and I thought the annotated version would be really helpful and interesting. Some notes were valuable to the modern reader on vocabulary and There is not much to review on the stories of literature's greatest detective.
Some notes were valuable to the modern reader on vocabulary and customs of Victorian England. However, most of the others seemed focused on 1 identifying specific places in London I've never been, so that doesn't hold much meaning for me or 2 identifying discrepancies in the Sherlock Holmes "historical timeline". Gerflint 2 : Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology.
Mumbai: Diligent Media Corporation. BBC News. Retrieved 6 June The Bend Bulletin. Bend, Oregon : Robert William Sawyer.
The Baker Street Babes | Podbay
Leeds Mercury. Retrieved 9 June — via British Newspaper Archive. Hull Daily Mail. Belfast News Letter. Cheltenham Looker-On. Hampshire Telegraph. The Daily Telegraph. London: Telegraph Media Group. Retrieved 8 June British Film Institute. Milwaukee: Applause Theatre and Cinema Books. Unreality TV. Archived from the original on 10 June Sherlock Holmes Handbook: Second Edition.
Related The Adventure of the Blue Carbuncle - Annotated Version (Focus on Sherlock Holmes Book 7)
Copyright 2019 - All Right Reserved